Machine Learning (Theory)

12/12/2008

Summer Conferences

Tags: Conferences,Machine Learning jl@ 6:35 pm

Here’s a handy table for the summer conferences.

Conference Deadline Reviewer Targeting Double Blind Author Feedback Location Date
ICML (wrong ICML) January 26 Yes Yes Yes Montreal, Canada June 14-17
COLT February 13 No No Yes Montreal June 19-21
UAI March 13 No Yes No Montreal June 19-21
KDD February 2/6 No No No Paris, France June 28-July 1

Reviewer targeting is new this year. The idea is that many poor decisions happen because the papers go to reviewers who are unqualified, and the hope is that allowing authors to point out who is qualified results in better decisions. In my experience, this is a reasonable idea to test.

Both UAI and COLT are experimenting this year as well with double blind and author feedback, respectively. Of the two, I believe author feedback is more important, as I’ve seen it make a difference. However, I still consider double blind reviewing a net win, as it’s a substantial public commitment to fairness.

4 Comments to “Summer Conferences”
  1. chintan says:

    Phew!! thanks for pointing out the wrong ICML.. i almost submitted my structural learning paper to them :)

  2. nimit says:

    “Reviewer Targeting” makes the trend of paper reviewing so interesting. In the past, we don’t know reviewers, but they know us. Now, it’s reverse!

  3. anjb says:

    BTW, UAI does have author feedback this year.

  4. jl says:

    That’s cool. Is it noted somewhere publicly? I don’t see it in the call for papers.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Powered by WordPress